Literary Blog Hop - I Won't Be Going There Again...
Thanks to The Blue Bookcase for hosting the always excellent Literary Blog Hop.
This weeks topic:
Discuss a work of literary merit that you hated when you were made to read it in school or university. Why did you dislike it?
At first I wasn't sure how to respond to this one. I have a personal philosophy that helped me get through grad school: I always like books. Even if I don't enjoy them, I search to find something that makes me excited about the material. I think, like many readers, I encountered some stuff in high school that was really boring, and no one really did anything to make it more exciting or relatable. I also think that I wasn't spending the time to understand the books, because I was far too busy doing other, teenager-y things. So, when I got to college and I saw how much I was going to be reading, I adopted my "make the best of it" attitude and eventually I really did start to find merit in most things.
That said, it suddenly came to me as I was pondering the topic. I hate Walden.
I'm probably not being entirely fair, because I don't think I've read all of Walden. I first encountered it in high school, where I'm sure I was supposed to read the whole thing. I remember the bean field chapter, and my only thought was, "Are you kidding? What on earth could I possibly be learning from reading about some guy who watches beans grow?" I was further disenchanted in college when I learned that Thoreau was not all that isolated at Walden pond. I slogged through the required selections in my American survey course. Then, when I was a TA for a writing class in Santa Cruz, we had seventh graders read it, and it started to come to life for me a little bit. I've always appreciated transcendentalist ideas, but the thought of reading Walden cover to cover makes me shudder.
Any Walden fanatics out there? I wish someone would convince me otherwise, but until then, Thoreau will remain collecting dust on my shelves.
Hi Laura,
ReplyDeleteYes, you're right: we share the same philosophy on the value of reading even books we find distasteful. I will say this: I simply won't read pulp fiction of any sort, because I want to continue to claim that even when I dislike a book, I can shift my reading experience into something beneficial to myself and others. I fear that some books have so little merit that I'd be hardpressed to do so, and thus I avoid them!
Thanks for visiting me, and I look forward to more of your thoughts as the weeks progress.
I too teach English, so perhaps that's why we agree on this aspect of reading.
L (www.whatsheread.blogspot.com)
If the person running the course, invests some passion, or can at least allow the book to live & by that I mean not constrict it in some formulaic textbook answers read in monotone, almost any book can be made interesting, it at least not deadly dull.
ReplyDeleteI have never read Walden cover to cover, although I did read excerpts in college. I can't say that I disliked it, but I wasn't enamored either. Interesting choice!
ReplyDeleteNice to have that philosophy. Sadly, most young readers don't live by those rules. Required Reading is poison to many.
ReplyDeleteMy post: http://readerbuzz.blogspot.com/2011/01/required-reading-dont-get-me-started.html
I remember feeling cheated when I learned Thoreau wasn't actually isolated as well! I had thought that was such a big point he was trying to make but obviously I missed what he was going for.
ReplyDeleteYes! I loved the book when I was young, but was incredibly disillusioned when I found out he took his laundry home to Mom regularly.
ReplyDeleteI think the secret to Walden is to read in small chunks, preferably in a silent, contemplative mood. It doesn't bother me so much that Thoreau wasn't completely isolated--it makes him human to me. I think you've got to love the man who says "Beware of all enterprises that require new clothes."
ReplyDeleteI have not read it. So can't comment.
ReplyDeleteSome books, you just can't get into!
Here is my Literary Blog Hop: Disliked Book post!
My read was STONEHENGE DECODED...uggh. Did anyone else have to suffer through it?
ReplyDeleteStop by my blog if you like...I also have a giveaway that isn't very literary, but check it out.
http://silversolara.blogspot.com
I've never read Walden, but it's one of those books I've always felt I should at least try. Maybe someday...
ReplyDelete